Edition #31: Why replies beat clicks for deliverability

A free newsletter with the marketing ideas you need

The best marketing ideas come from marketers who live it. That’s what The Marketing Millennials delivers: real insights, fresh takes, and no fluff. Written by Daniel Murray, a marketer who knows what works, this newsletter cuts through the noise so you can stop guessing and start winning. Subscribe and level up your marketing game.

Sign Up Free

Today's Email: Edition #31: Why replies beat clicks for deliverability

Hello email aficionados,

As usual, we're sharing the most valuable reads to make email marketing successful:

• Why replies are the strongest engagement signal you can send, and how to actually get them

• The six segmentation types worth building, and how unsegmented lists kill your deliverability

• A referral invite email that gets personal, buries nothing, and funnels everything to one button

✉️ How to write emails people actually reply to

Marketing emails aren't designed to get replies. They're designed to get clicks.

That works fine for promotions and product launches. But if you want to build a real relationship with your list, replies change everything.

A reply is the strongest engagement signal you can send to a mailbox provider. Stronger than an open. Stronger than a click. When someone replies to your email, Gmail basically says: this sender is a real person having a real conversation. That's inbox placement gold.

So how do you write emails people actually respond to?

Write like one person talking to one person

Most brand emails read like announcements from a company. Nobody replies to an announcement.

Compare:

"We're excited to announce our new feature that helps teams collaborate better."

vs.

"We just shipped something I think will save you a couple hours a week. Curious if it lands for you."

The second one sounds like a person wrote it. That's the difference.

Ask a real question

Not a rhetorical one. Not "Ready to level up your strategy?" Nobody responds to that.

Ask something specific that people can answer in one sentence.

"What's the one thing you wish your email tool did better?" "What topic should we cover next week?" "Did this actually help, or was it too basic?"

If the question takes more than 10 seconds to answer, most people won't bother.

Reply to the replies

This sounds obvious but most teams don't do it. Someone takes the time to respond to your email and gets silence back. That's the fastest way to make sure they never reply again.

Even a short "Thanks, really appreciate this" keeps the loop alive. And every reply back and forth strengthens your sender reputation further.

When to use this approach

Not every email needs replies. Promos, transactional, and product updates are fine as one-way sends.

But your welcome sequence? Your newsletter? Your re-engagement flow? Those are the places where a reply can do more for your deliverability and your relationship than any click ever will.

📧 Common Types of Email Segmentation

There's a version of your list that's working against you right now. Subscribers who haven't opened in nine months, sitting in the same segment as your most engaged buyers, dragging down your deliverability and skewing everything you think you know about what's working.

Segmentation is how you stop that. Not just for re-engagement, though that's part of it. For everything. What you send, when you send it, how often. The subscribers who want to hear from you every day are different from the ones who want one email a week. The people who just joined are different from the ones who've been around long enough to buy.

When you send each person what they actually want, they stick around. When you send everyone the same thing, the ones it doesn't fit quietly stop opening. Then stop clicking. Then unsubscribe, or worse, mark you as spam.

This article breaks down the six segmentation types that matter and how to think about building each one.

📫️ From the inbox

This email is from Wispr Flow. It's a referral invite email that uses social proof and a free month of Pro to convert the referred user.

Here's what we liked in this email:

• The headline does all the work. "Your friend invited you to Wispr Flow." Italicizing "friend" makes it feel personal, not promotional. You're not getting marketed to. Someone you know sent this.

• The offer is clear and bolded. "Free month of Flow Pro" is bold in the body copy so even skimmers catch it. No burying the incentive in a paragraph.

• One CTA, one action. "Claim your free month." No competing links, no secondary asks. The entire email funnels to one button.

• The testimonial punches up, not sideways. The quote compares Wispr Flow to Apple's built-in dictation and calls it "embarrassingly outdated." That positions the product against something the reader already uses and finds lacking. Real person, real photo, real handle.

• "Written with Wispr Flow" in the footer. Subtle product demo. The email itself was made with the tool. That's proof baked into the format, not the copy.

👀 Worth the read

• The Inbox Decoded: How Mailbox Providers Really Think About Email 

• Email Marketing for SaaS 101: Engage, Retain, and Scale

Best,
Alec

P.S. Have a topic you’d like us to cover in the next edition? Reply to this email and let us know! We're always eager to address.